Hank Scorpio
Leaving Skid Marks
Well in the end it's up to you. But personally I would go the larger profile to keep the rolling diametre close to stock. And I also don't like the look of licorice straps.
As I posted before though the smaller profile keeps it closer to stock, 215/45 is a much larger size (basically the same height as a 245/40 that you would see on the Evo X).
Just go 225/40R18 dude, sweet tyre size and when talking about an 8" rim on a VR-4 stretch will be minimal whatever you put on.